GST on Free Corporate Guarantees: Delhi HC Reads Down 1% Valuation Rule

Category:
Updates - GST
Published:
Read time:
5 min

Overview: The Delhi High Court has ruled that corporate guarantees provided by parent companies for subsidiary loans attract GST even when no fee is charged. However, it read down Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, holding that the prescribed 1% annual valuation is a rebuttable benchmark, not an absolute minimum. Companies can establish a lower open-market value through reliable evidence, although the taxability of the guarantee itself remains.

————————– 

Parent companies providing guarantees for subsidiary loans remain liable to GST, even without charging a fee. However, the 1% valuation benchmark can be challenged with evidence of a lower open-market value.

The ruling came in Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., along with connected petitions involving companies from the power, renewable energy and infrastructure sectors.

The dispute concerned two issues: whether a parent company’s free corporate guarantee is a taxable service to its subsidiary, and whether GST authorities can automatically value it at 1% of the guaranteed amount every year. The Delhi High Court addressed both questions and clarified how the rules apply to guarantees issued during different periods.

Key Points and Their Effects

1. Free Corporate Guarantees Attract GST

The Court held that a parent company provides a service when it gives a corporate guarantee to support a subsidiary’s borrowing. By assuming the risk of default and making its credit standing available, the parent provides a benefit to the subsidiary.

Under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I to the CGST Act, supplies between related persons in the course or furtherance of business can be taxable even without consideration. Therefore, the absence of a guarantee fee does not, by itself, remove the GST liability.

2. The 1% Valuation Is Not an Absolute Minimum

Rule 28(2), effective from 26th October, 2023, prescribes a value equal to 1% of the guaranteed amount per annum or the actual consideration, whichever is higher.

The Court upheld the government’s authority to frame the rule but read it down to prevent the 1% figure from operating as an irrebuttable minimum. It is a rebuttable benchmark. A company can establish a lower open-market value through cogent and verifiable evidence, such as relevant Ind AS 109 valuation, accepted transfer-pricing benchmarks or credit-rating-based assessments. An internal decision to provide the guarantee free of charge, on its own, is not sufficient.

3. Full ITC Eligibility Continues to Matter

Where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit (ITC), the invoice value is accepted as the open-market value under the proviso to Rule 28(2). However, companies must establish full ITC eligibility on the facts. It should not be assumed merely because the entities belong to the same group.

4. GST Is Not Charged Afresh Every Year

The Court treated the guarantee as a single supply made when it is issued and delivered. GST is determined at the time of supply for the guarantee’s entire tenure; its continued existence does not create a fresh supply every year. Any permitted annual instalment arrangement would concern collection of the tax, not a separate annual supply.

A renewal, extension or enhancement of the guarantee creates a fresh taxable event. Invocation by the lender following a default does not, by itself, attract an additional GST levy.

5. Treatment Depends on the Date of the Guarantee

No. Period of issue or relevant modification GST treatment Applicability of Rule 28(2)
1 Before 1st July 2017 No GST, unless renewed, extended or enhanced on or after GST commencement Not applicable
2 1st July 2017 to 25th Oct 2023 GST may apply under the valuation rules then in force Not applicable
3 On or after 26th Oct 2023 GST applies, subject to the applicable valuation provisions 1% benchmark applies, but a lower value may be established with evidence

The Court set aside the impugned notices and demands only to the extent that they were inconsistent with its findings. The court also said that the matters may be reassessed after giving the affected taxpayers an opportunity to be heard. It did not grant a blanket cancellation of all GST demands on corporate-guarantee.

What Companies Need to Do

Companies with parent-subsidiary guarantees should:

  1. Review existing guarantees: Record their issue dates and identify subsequent renewals, extensions or enhancements.
  2. Check valuation records: For guarantees covered by Rule 28(2), retain reliable evidence if the actual open-market value is lower than the prescribed benchmark.
  3. Confirm ITC eligibility: Examine the recipient’s supplies and applicable restrictions before relying on the full-ITC proviso.
  4. Review pending GST matters: Reassess notices, demands and earlier tax positions in light of the judgment, taking professional advice where valuation or litigation issues arise.

Setindiabiz Support

Corporate groups must keep their GST registrations, returns, reconciliations and supporting records in order, including records relating to related-party transactions. 

Setindiabiz supports businesses with GST registration, return filing, reconciliation and ongoing compliance requirements. Companies reviewing corporate guarantees can also use these compliance records as part of their wider review of GST exposure. Specialist valuation opinions and representation in tax disputes should be handled by professionals qualified in those areas.

FAQs

The Delhi High Court has confirmed that free corporate guarantees between related companies can attract GST, while preventing the 1% valuation benchmark from being applied mechanically. Companies should review the dates, terms, valuation records and ITC position of their guarantees before taking a tax position. The wider issue also remains subject to further consideration by the Supreme Court.


whatsapp-link-logo.webp
Reach Us